Home | Puzzles | declarer play | Puzzles * | Is this an either/or situation? Or...? *
Is this an either/or situation? Or...? *
S/—
K 6 2 
 A 2
8 3 2
A K 10 9 8
  windroos  
    
 A 7 5 4 
K 9
K Q J 5
J 5 4

WestNorthEastSouth
1
pass2pass2NT
pass3NTpasspass
pass   

West leads the 5.

Solution

Declarer counts six top tricks: the AK, the AK and the AK. So he has to develop three extra tricks. Is he going to set op the clubs or the diamonds?
Suppose he finesses for the Q. If he succeeds, nine tricks are there. But if East wins with the Q, declarer is almost certainly defeated:

 K 6 2 
 A 2
8 3 2
A K 10 9 8
J 9 8windroosQ 10 3
Q 10 7 6 5J 8 4 3
9 7 4
A 10 6
7 6Q 3 2
 A 7 5 4 
K 9
K Q J 5
J 5 4

...since EW set up their heart suit. As soon as declarer plays a diamond — in order to set up his ninth trick; after all he has only eight tricks to take — the defence wins with the A and cashes at least three more hearts (in this case exactly three).
So by finessing for the Q declarer puts all his eggs in one basket: a 50% chance of success.

Declarer can do much better by combining chances: he wins the lead with the A, cashes the A (you never know...) and plays a diamond from dummy. If East has the A (a 50% chance), the contract is made:
- If East wins with the A, South has three master diamonds, enough for his contract.
- If East ducks, South scores the K. With a diamond trick in the bag and still a heart guard, declarer now changes tack by finessing for the Q, not caring too much whether the finesse wins or fails.
If it wins, he cashes the clubs and switches back to diamonds, making eleven (diamonds not 3-3) or twelve tricks.
If the club finesse fails (the actual layout), he safely makes nine tricks.

If, on a different layout, West wins with the A and clears the hearts, declarer first tests the diamonds. If this suit is 3-3 (a 35.5% chance), he has nine tricks. If not, he tries his last chance: the club finesse (50%).

Following this line of play, declarer will only be defeated if West has the A and the diamond suit is not 3-3 and East has the Q. The total chance of defeat is 16.8%. If declarer suffers that fate, he has reason to complain...

 

Top Tips

New: Barry and Harry

Starting the 5th of march 2010: bridge adventures of the twins Barry and Harry in stories/Barry and Harry